Portfolio Allocation by Signal
A deterministic rule applied to mplot's readings as of April 30, 2026 — with a six-month scorecard
Signal Snapshot — as of 2026-04-30
Recession Prob
28.3%
Liquidity Z
-0.8σ
Sahm Rule
0.2
10Y-3M
0.7%
Crypto F&G
29.0
Strong Buy
ETH
Allocation as Signal
Most market commentary treats portfolio allocation as opinion. This post treats it as a signal-processing problem: given the current state of every quantitative input mplot tracks, what allocation does the data imply? The output is a deterministic function of the signals — not a forecast, not a recommendation, just the position the model holds when forced to decide.
The exercise is useful for two reasons. First, it forces the analytical apparatus to commit to a number. Second, it makes the model's behavior observable: when readers return next month, they can see what changed and why, rather than reading another opinion piece.
The methodology and triggers are explicit below. Replicate, criticize, or replace as needed.
Methodology
The allocation rule is intentionally minimal:
- Universe: Ten assets tracked by the multi-factor scanner — broad equity (SPY, QQQ, IWM, EFA, EEM), bonds (TLT, HYG), gold (GLD), and crypto (BTC, ETH).
- Inclusion: Only assets with positive multi-factor composite score are eligible. The composite weights momentum (40%), carry (30%), and value (30%).
- Sizing: Allocations are proportional to composite signal strength, then capped per asset class to control concentration: 30% bonds, 25% high-yield credit, 25% equity, 8% per crypto position.
- Cash reserve: 15% base, plus 5% if recession probability exceeds 25%, plus 5% if the liquidity z-score is below -0.5. Both adjustments are currently active, producing a 25% reserve floor.
- Overflow: When position caps bind, residual capital is iteratively redistributed across non-capped positive-signal assets. Anything that cannot be placed accrues to cash.
The rule does not consider correlation, factor crowding, transaction costs, or tax. Those are second-order. The first-order question is which assets the cross-sectional signal currently favors, and the methodology answers that with one composite per asset.
What the Model Holds
As of April 30, 2026, four assets clear the positive-composite threshold: TLT (+0.62), BTC (+0.71), HYG (+0.51), and ETH (+1.07). All other assets — including SPY, QQQ, GLD, and EFA — register zero or negative composite scores and receive no allocation under the rule.
The resulting portfolio is heavily defensive. Long-duration treasuries take the maximum 30% allocation, supported by strong carry (+1.04) and historically cheap valuation (+1.51). High-yield credit fills 25%, driven entirely by the highest carry score in the universe (+2.16) — HYG's 5.9% yield offers more cushion against capital risk than any other asset class currently tracked. The remaining risk-taking is concentrated in 8% positions in BTC and ETH, where the multi-factor model registers strong momentum (+1.63 and +1.92) and positive value relative to five-year price history. Cash absorbs the residual 29%.
The absence of equity exposure in this allocation is the single most counterintuitive feature. SPY rallied roughly 8% over the past six weeks, which is reflected in its positive momentum score (+0.28). But that single positive factor is overwhelmed by SPY's negative value score (-0.81), reflecting an estimated CAPE near 41 — well above any reasonable historical anchor. The composite (-0.11) is therefore slightly negative, and the rule excludes it. This is a feature, not a bug: a methodology that buys equities at every CAPE level provides no information; one that occasionally refuses to is at least falsifiable.
Factor Decomposition
The multi-factor breakdown clarifies why the model holds what it holds. ETH and BTC score positive across two of three factors (momentum strongly, value mildly) and negative on carry — the standard crypto signature. TLT and HYG are mirror images: weak momentum, strong carry, and (for TLT) strong value. Gold, conventionally framed as a hedge in the current environment, scores negative on all three factors: momentum has rolled over after the early-2026 highs, carry is structurally negative, and value remains stretched against its five-year mean. The model assigns it zero weight despite the macro narrative.
The decomposition also highlights the disagreement between short- and long-window momentum. The standalone momentum scanner (63-day) ranks SPY first; the multi-factor model penalizes SPY's valuation and ranks crypto first. Neither view is correct in isolation. The composite is the resolution.
Triggers
The allocation is not static. The trigger dashboard lists the six signals whose state changes would force a re-allocation, along with the threshold and direction.
Two triggers are particularly close to firing. First, the Sahm Rule sits at 0.20, well below its 0.50 threshold — but the recession-probability composite (28.3%) is already past the 25% threshold that activated the recession-related cash adjustment. A 20-25 basis-point increase in the unemployment trend would push the rule meaningfully closer. Second, the liquidity z-score at -0.85 is deep in tightening territory. A reversal toward zero would not change the allocation; only a sustained move above +0.5 (an Easing regime confirmation) would prompt a substantial increase in equity and crypto exposure at the expense of cash.
The remaining triggers are farther out. A re-inversion of the 10Y-3M curve from +0.67 would call for extending bond duration. A move in crypto Fear & Greed from 29 to above 75 would prompt taking profits in BTC and ETH. A reversal in gold's multi-factor score from -1.07 to above +0.5 would re-introduce a 10% gold position. These are not predictions — they are the conditions under which the model would change its mind.
| Signal | Apr 30, 2026 | Threshold | Distance | Action if Triggered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sahm Rule | 0.2 | ≥ 0.5 | 60% away | Recession confirmed — cut risk: equity 0%, cash 50% |
| Recession Probability | 28.3% | ≥ 35.0% | 19% away | Reduce risk-on assets, increase TLT toward 30% |
| Liquidity Z-Score | -0.85σ | ≥ +0.50σ | — | Easing regime confirmed: add SPY 25%, BTC 10%, reduce cash to 5% |
| Crypto Fear & Greed | 29 | ≥ 75 | 61% away | Take crypto profits — reduce BTC + ETH to ~3% combined |
| 10Y-3M Spread | 0.7% | ≤ -0.1% | — | Re-inversion: extend bond duration, equity underweight |
| GLD Multi-Factor Score | -1.07σ | ≥ +0.50σ | — | Re-add 10% gold position as inflation hedge |
Limitations
This methodology is one model, not the model. Five points of honest caveat:
The composite weights (40/30/30) are heuristic, not optimized. A different weighting could materially change rankings, particularly for assets where momentum and value disagree.
The vol-based caps (8% crypto, 25% equity, 30% bonds) are imposed by hand, not derived. They reflect risk-management intuition but are not the output of any optimization.
The CAPE-driven negative value score for equities assumes mean reversion to a historical anchor. If valuations are structurally higher in the AI/productivity-growth regime, the model is overweighting that signal.
The cash reserve logic uses two binary thresholds rather than a continuous function. A continuous version would be more elegant but offers little practical difference at current levels.
Most importantly: this allocation has not been backtested. The rule is observable going forward; whether it produces returns above a 60/40 benchmark is an empirical question that requires several years of out-of-sample data to answer.
The point of publishing it is not to claim performance. It is to commit to a methodology in advance, so that future readings of mplot can be evaluated against a real prior.
Six-Month Scorecard (added 2026-11-17)
This section was added six and a half months after publication. Nothing above it has been edited.
Realized performance, April 30 → November 17, 2026 (Yahoo adjusted closes, total return; cash proxied by SHY):
| Position | Weight | Return | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Long Treasury (TLT) | 30.0% | −4.7% | −1.41 pp |
| High Yield (HYG) | 25.0% | −1.2% | −0.29 pp |
| Bitcoin | 8.0% | −15.0% | −1.20 pp |
| Ethereum | 8.0% | −19.4% | −1.55 pp |
| Cash (SHY) | 29.0% | +0.6% | +0.17 pp |
| Model portfolio | −4.3% | ||
| SPY | +3.5% | ||
| 60/40 (SPY/AGG) | +1.4% |
The model underperformed SPY by 7.8 points and 60/40 by 5.7. Decomposed: not owning SPY forwent its +3.5%; the remaining 4.3 points are losses on positions actually held. Those losses came from long duration into a Federal Reserve that raised its target to 3.75–4.00% rather than cutting, and from two crypto positions whose Buy / Strong Buy composites did not survive the next six months. Ethereum — the single highest-conviction signal in the April ranking at +1.07 — fell 19.4%. The one unambiguously correct call was the one the rule excluded: gold's Strong Sell (−1.07) preceded a 16.7% decline.
What the rule would hold today. Re-running the same composite on November 17: TLT +1.24 (Strong Buy), HYG +0.90 (Buy), SPY +0.04 (Hold — now marginally eligible), BTC −0.27, ETH −0.58, GLD −0.63. The rule has rotated out of crypto on its own and still favors duration.
The trigger that crossed. The liquidity trigger (snapshot z-score ≥ +0.5) crossed on November 11 — regime "Easing", z = +0.53 — four trading days before this note, so not yet "sustained." Two caveats the April text did not anticipate. First, mplot computed this z-score in more than one place with different windows: the signal snapshot works on a business-day index, so its 252 observations span about one trading year, and reads +0.53; the Liquidity Regime page resampled to calendar days, so its 252 observations spanned only about eight months, and reads +0.08. Same name, different quantity — a defect catalogued in the November platform review, and a reason to treat the trigger as unconfirmed. (Corrected the same day, 2026-11-17: an earlier version of this sentence attributed the gap to a weekly, five-year window. Recomputing both conventions directly from FRED gave +0.475 for business-day and +0.085 for calendar-day, identifying the real cause. The platform now uses the single business-day definition everywhere.) Second, the prescribed action ("add SPY 25%, BTC 10%") conflicts with the composite rule itself, which rates BTC a Hold. The dashboard above shows April's readings and has not been updated. The other triggers did not fire: Sahm Rule 0.00 (moved away from 0.50), 10Y–3M +0.78 (no re-inversion), crypto Fear & Greed 12 (Extreme Fear — the opposite of the >75 take-profit), gold composite −0.63 (no re-entry).
Assessment. The methodology did what it promised: it committed to a number and is now measurable. The number is bad. Two inputs were weaker than the April text implied. The equity "carry" factor was a proxy (trailing 12-month return × 0.15) with no empirical basis; it has since been removed, and equity and crypto carry now enter as neutral. The crypto rankings rested on a 63-day momentum reading that reversed. Neither fully explains a 7.8-point gap, which also reflects a Fed path — hike, not hold — that none of the inputs anticipated. This is the first entry in the live record the April text promised; the next will use the same format.